Lighting

This task is about advantages and disadvantages of different sorts of lights.

Shane and Elena are choosing how to light a room. They can get the room to the same brightness by using the lights shown in the table.

Type of light	Number needed to get the same brightness	Total energy used every second (joules)	How long does it last?
	120 candles	4800 J	2 hours
	1 low energy bulb	18 J	2 years
	1 filament bulb	100 J	9 months

Images source: Wikipedia

a)	i)	Which type of lighting would be good if there was an electrical power cut? ____________________
	ii)	Explain your choice.

Which type of lighting is best for saving energy? ____________________

ii)

Explain your choice.

The candles and bulbs all produce light and heat. The table shows lighting that produces the same amount of light.

Which type of lighting produces least heat energy? ____________________

ii)

Explain your choice.

Fill in the table below, describing one advantage (good thing) and one disadvantage (bad thing) of each type of light.

Type of light	Advantage	Disadvantage
i) Candle
ii) Low energy bulb
iii) Filament bulb

Teaching and learning:

Background information
This task was trialled at Years 4, 6, 8, and 10. Student responses can therefore be compared across the levels. (Note that following the trial the task was simplified to make it more relevant for L 2 students. Go to Lighting Shane's bedroom.)

Science information is often presented in tables, so learning about tables and how to read them helps students to interpret data presented in this format. Understanding the strengths and weaknesses of presenting information in a table is a precursor to choosing when tables are the best option for presenting their own data.

Electricity consumption has both environmental and economic impacts. The context of lighting is one that students can be involved in decision-making in their own lives. The questions support skill-building that enables students to evaluate information.

The key ideas that are covered in the task are shown in the table below.

Nature of science idea

Science knowledge

Communicating in science

Tables are one way we can show science information.

Physical concepts

Some lighting gets its energy from electricity.
Different types of lighting use different amounts of energy.
The amount of energy a light uses can be measured.

Diagnostic and formative information:

Nature of science: Communicating in science (tables)

Most students seemed to be familiar with tables as a way of presenting information. In general terms they knew how to read the first table, although did not always interpret the detail well. Most of those who attempted filling in the second one were able to enter their responses in the correct place.
However, there is also evidence that some students didn't use the table to answer questions, relying more on their background knowledge. This was particularly obvious in Question d). Year 8 students appeared to be less able to correctly answer this question than Year 6 students. One reason may be that Year 8 students were more likely to be using the table to find the answers rather than using background information, but often misinterpreted the data contained in it. A second reason was that Year 8 students were more likely than Year 6 and Year 10 students to interpret the information that candles and bulbs produce heat (and light) in Question c) as an advantage and use this to answer Question d). Few Year 6 students were cued by Question c) to associate heat as either an advantage or disadvantage in Question d) and Year 10 students were more aware than the younger students that heat was a disadvantage, i.e., an inefficiency of lighting.

The areas that caused difficulties were:

Many students (including at higher levels) indicated that a disadvantage of low-energy bulbs was that they were dimmer than other bulbs. Three possible reasons for this response are:

They did not pay attention to the heading that indicated that the lights produced the same amount of brightness; or
They interpreted joules as a measurement of brightness; or
This is an often-expressed opinion that students may have heard. Their personal theory about low-energy lights may have led them to ignore the information in the table.

It was slightly more difficult for students to suggest an advantage for candles than a disadvantage, whereas the opposite was the case with the filament bulb. However, it was noticeably more difficult to give a disadvantage than advantage of low-energy bulbs.

Science concept: lighting

Scientific vocabulary
Younger students often used the words "power", "energy" and "electricity" interchangeably (as we are inclined to do in our everyday conversations), but older students were much less likely to. For Question b) about a sixth of Year 6 and Year 8 students chose the candles as being best for saving energy. Most gave reasons that showed they interpreted energy as electrical power, therefore equating "saving energy" with not using electrical power. If your students did have an issue with the specialised vocabulary go to Lighting Shane's bedroom for more information.

Question c): The relationship between heat and light
Few students at Years 6 and 8 gave a complete answer for this question although many were starting to make a link to either the amount of energy used (usually) or (less often) the amount of light produced, for example:

Because it uses least power. Year 6
It uses 18 J and lasts 2 years. Year 8
Because it does not use as much energy as the other two. Year 10

About a fifth of Year 6 students gave a partial answer and about a half gave a wrong answer or did not attempt to answer. This number had risen to a third of Year 8 students as more of them were attempting to give a more logical explanation (about a fifth getting it wrong or not attempting an explanation). At Year 10 about a fifth of the students were still giving a partial answer but about a third were now giving a good explanation which linked the different factors (about a fifth were getting it wrong or not attempting an explanation).

Example of a good explanation:
Low energy bulbs only use 18J so very little energy is lost to heat. Year 10

Examples of good explanations that made links to both energy use and heat from younger students even though there are some gaps in their explanations:

Because it uses the least energy which means it gives off the least heat. Year 8
Well, fire produces a lot of heat but light bulbs don't. The more energy you have the more heat you have and a filament bulb has a lot more energy so the low energy bulb produces the least heat. Year 6

Misconceptions
Some students' responses suggested misconceptions about electric lights.

Student response	Likely misconception
Because it's got something round it to stop the heat coming out. Year 6 All the heat gets stored inside and can't get out. Year 8	A light bulb contains or has heat.
(A disadvantage of a filament bulb is there is) not as much heat as from candles. Year 8	Considers producing heat is an advantage. Do not make the connection that less heat is desirable because the bulb is then more efficient at its primary function, producing light.
(A candle produces least heat energy) because it lasts two hours. Year 6	Associates heat produced with the amount of time the light lasts, rather than calculating from the total joules used. Possibly does not recognise that heat and light are both forms of energy.
(A candle produces least heat energy) because they have light and heat. Year 8	Heat is only associated with the candle.

Next steps:

Give students practice in interpreting what the table is about. Include careful attention to the headings used, as well as the relationships between the columns. Encourage students to look both across one row (which in this table tells you about each type of light) and down the columns (to compare the different lights). Ask questions such as:

What story can we tell about the candles (light bulb, low-energy bulb) from looking at the table?
What can we tell about how much energy a candle and a low-energy bulb use?
The table doesn't tell us where candles or the bulbs get energy to make light. How do you think we can make them light up? How could we check our ideas? (These questions relate to what the table doesn't tell us but assumes we know.)

Students are more likely to be able to answer Question c) if they have some understanding of the science, and also can interpret the table. Students with strong science knowledge can probably answer the question without reference to the table (they already know the answer), and students experienced in reading tables also have a good chance of explaining their answer without knowing as much about the science (they can work it out.). Developing the understanding of science concepts and using them to make sense of text, including tables, can be addressed together to increase understanding.

Ask questions that require students to make calculations or inferences from the data provided. Advertisements that provide data about low energy lighting can be a useful source for students to work with.
Students can set up investigations to investigate their ideas about the relationship between light and heat output. They should be encouraged to share and debate their explanations with others.

			Y6 (03/2010)	Y8 (03/2010)	Y10 (03/2010)
a)	i)	Candle	very easy	very easy	very easy
a)	ii)	Any answer that shows an understanding that it isn't powered by electricity	easy	easy	easy
b)	i)	Low energy bulb	easy	easy	very easy
b)	ii)	Any answer that shows an understanding that it uses up less energy	easy	easy	easy
c)	i)	Low energy bulb	moderate	easy	easy
c)	ii)	As they all produce the same amount of light the light source using the least amount of energy produces the least heat.	very difficult	very difficult	difficult
d)	i)	Describes an advantage (e.g., it doesn't need electricity, it is cheap to buy, it is portable) and a disadvantage (e.g., you need 120 to get the same brightness, it only lasts 2 hours, it can cause fires, it can blow out).	easy	moderate	easy
	ii)	Describes an advantage (e.g., it is economical, you only need one, it uses less electricity than a filament bulb, it doesn't waste energy on heat/doesn't get hot, it lasts a long time) and a disadvantage (e.g., it uses electrical energy, it is expensive to buy).	difficult	very difficult	difficult
	iii)	Describes an advantage (e.g., it is cheap to buy, you only need one, it lasts longer than a candle) and a disadvantage (e.g., it uses a lot of electricity, it only lasts for 9 months, it gets hot).	difficult	difficult	difficult

You are here

Resource user links

Lighting

Lighting